West of the Hudson – Evolution of an American City. Robert Crisman Rants. Again.
By MichaelSolender on January 31, 2010 in MiscellaneousEditor’s note: You have to really love your city to be critical of its evolution. Far too easily overlooked by the literati and the media is what happens west of the Hudson River. Seattle? Yeah doesn’t Bill Gates live there? Jeff Bezos and Amazon? Oh yeah them too. Is Washington a blue state?? It rains a lot in Seattle doesn’t it? Turns out there is quite a bit going on there, just ask Robert Crisman.
DRY ROT
by Robert Crisman
Sometimes Seattle’s the next thing to heaven. The sky’s diamond blue, the sun’s a caress; your whole soul can breathe. You know what the shouting’s about. But the sun quickly fades to Protestant gray and the gray lasts a long time.
Still, things have changed…
Fifties Seattle was hidebound, provincial, surrounded by mountains and water and stuck upper-left on the map, away from the action. A hick Norwegian crew cut kind of a place, like stew without salt.
Culture was bush-league: hydroplanes, Seafair, Triple-A baseball, accordion players in bowties named Stan getting down with the two-step in lounges. The jazz riffs on Jackson were gnarls and mutters in dreams as the square-johns slept on.
Dads put on suits and went to the office or did what they did down at Boeing. Moms stayed home and took care of the kids. The kids were all fresh-faced and cheery and bright. The place was Leave-It-To-Beaverland North.
Or so went the story. Nobody spoke of the suicide rate, up there with Sweden’s. Or dad’s weekend binges and mom’s hidden bruises. Or Wally and Beaver, torturing cats in the alley to work off their blues. That stuff got swept out of sight like the date-rapes out on Frat Row at U Dub.
This was the deal: Seattle was “middleclass” down to the bone. See, what it was, a lot of the wage slaves thought they’d stepped out of the pits since the war. The U.S. was rich, the only rich country left on the planet. The factories and offices were humming, the money was rolling—war spending in peacetime could do that back then—and enough shekels fell into working folks’ pockets that many forgot that they were merely the means to make rich fuckers richer. Class in the ‘30s meant who owned the works and who slaved for nickels: capitalists, workers, that old commie shit. But after the war, McCarthy stormed in, the commies got rolled, and all their ideas got tossed out the window. Madison Avenue then sold the serfs a big line of bullshit, i.e., the notion that class just meant income. There were rich folks and poor folks, like always, of course, and then all those folks in the middle.
Just for a moment, pretend you’re Ward Cleaver. You’ve moved to Seattle, and this is your life; if ever a man stood smack-dab in the middle… You’ve got the house and the wife and the kids, and the nice, brand-new car. You’re thinking of buying a boat—easy credit!—and the Beav will make college no sweat. And when you retire, you’ll still have enough left for supper. Meanwhile, your lovely wife June’s like a chef in that kitchen! What’s not to like?
Sure, they sweat you down at the office, and, yeah, your boss just bought a new island so he can tryst with his bimbos in style—and then stacked your workload so he can catch up when he’s back—but so what? You get to wear a nice suit and tie, and the car’s almost paid for. It’s different these days. The sky is the limit! You too could be rich! You can get on a quiz show, any damn thing! Just stay in step with the program and you’ve got it dicked!
Hell, even Joe Six-pack down at the shipyards keeps change in his pockets. The man has a house and a car, the whole bit, almost. His union dumped all its commies, kissed up to the fat-cats, and worked out a deal: throw crumbs our way and we’ll keep our mouths shut, and stand for the National Anthem at ballgames, and send our kids off to shoot dinks in the war…
Joe went and wangled a middleclass lifestyle. Well, close enough. Life sure was good for most of the white folks, you know? And, all that working class bullshit? That class warfare shit that the commies and pinkos and fags were trying to stir up in the ‘30s? Deader than Edsels, my brother, way deader than Edsels…
Don’t misunderstand: some wage slaves got left way behind, in go-nowhere jobs or on welfare, or just, they fell through some crack. You know, like I said, there’s always the poor folks. But dig this about them: since you hit the middle, they seem to be mostly black folks or brown folks—with maybe some Okies and hillbillies scattered around from the ‘30s or something. You always knew you were different from them, am I right? Now, here’s more proof: your Ward Cleaver life! You never see them playing catch with the Beav on prime time TV! They’re just some statistics, the crime news and so forth…
Of course, there’s that civil rights stuff, and, well, you guess you support it. Hell, you’re a liberal of sorts. It’s just, well, tell the truth, you wouldn’t want a bunch of them living next door…
I mean, it’s okay, they can vote and get jobs and all that, as long as they’re kind of off to the side, out of mind…
Yes, out of sight, out of mind…
Old Ward was a trip. And, like I said, ‘50s Seattle was Leave-It-To-Beaverland North. Out of sight, out of mind all the way. Social Ills? Pardon? There’s nobody here but us white folks, soaking up ads for toilet bowl cleanser and trying to forget where we came from!
Okay then, but, hey—what about cops getting fat rousting gay bars in Pioneer Square? Or jacking up black kids for fun up on Cherry? Or Indians, ripped off and raped, lying stark puking drunk in the gutters downtown? Are you kidding? Blacks hadn’t yet started riots. Indians were day-before-yesterday’s news. Gays were deep secrets. Who gave a rusty rat’s ass? Besides them?
Those were the days. The Lone Ranger rode…
But then Kennedy got bushwhacked, the ‘60s revved up, and Seattle, like everywhere else, got plugged into politics and dope. The whole social bag got to shaking and baking. You could hear sphincters cracking from burbs to the boardrooms, and in white city enclaves as well.
And—poor old Ward! It wouldn’t be long before June would be burning her bra and Wally was brought up on heroin charges. The worst, though, was catching the Beaver in bed with some rough trade. Two of the fuckers! One of them had a spike through his dick!
You know Ward felt that one…
Don’t get me wrong. Rude shocks notwithstanding, life was still soft here compared with, say, Newark. You could work or not work and somehow still eat. Even a lame could keep change in his pockets. Rent was way cheap. Our riots here were popgun affairs next to Watts…
City fathers were more or less liberal. You could even blow dope on the sidewalks downtown in the daytime and nobody would sweat it. The square-johns were trying to get hip…
Then the ‘70s landed like green, toxic fog. Seattle crash-landed and woke up strung out. Boeing went tits to the sky. Aerospace workers learned to flip burgers at Wendy’s or boogied, or fought off the winos for space on park benches. The lights all winked out. Junkies crawled out of their holes then, and liberals went into “strategic retreat”…
You should have seen downtown. Ghosts bumming smokes in the doorways on First, running north out of Pioneer Square, up through Belltown. History, heritage, smothered in shit.
Take Pioneer Square, where Seattle popped out of the ground and got grabby. Where profits got rolling and Leschi got rolled. The thin, wintry heart of Seattle—until after the war when the last of the money fled uptown. Then the winos took over and the place slid into d-t’s. Nothing was left then but vomit and pigeons, gay bars in shadows, and Indian kids sleeping twelve to a room in the flops.
And so on up First. This street had been the honky-tonk playground for sailors and hustlers and chippies and hos through two world wars. By the ‘60s, however, First was a graveyard for shit-bums and drifters in piss-smelling bars and two-dollar rooms. Block after block, the brick and brownstone facades of the old office buildings blackened and buckled. “For Lease” signs in cracked, soot-stained windows turned yellow, fell over, and died.
The ‘70s ran like a nightmare down there, especially at night. Porno took over the corner where First runs past Pike Place. Tourists wandered the Market by day. By night, peepshow flotsam: dopers and skulks, low-bottom dick-snatchers, runaways selling their asses to sneaky-petes circling the block.
Imagine yourself on that street in those years with no place to go, shambling around like a zombie at four in the morning, when even the winos have clocked out for home, or wherever. No one and nothing but you—and creeps standing guard in the doorways, autistic wreckage in old army coats, and bad breath and werewolves. A miasma of dank, dark decay. Who’d ever have thought that hell was so empty!
Time marches on: In ’75, the street was a cesspool. These days, it’s cold, gleaming towers and cold, fast-track spenders. The bones of the ghosts have all been paved over. A blitzkrieg of progress: Ghosts, six feet under; the gelid indifference and bland, sneering laughter of mutants with money; dreams, sucked from marrow in gutters…
Ah yes, money, money. By ’75, Seattle in fact had already started to bounce its way back from the Big Boeing Bust that had punched out its lights at the start of the decade. Hot plans were drafted, to ride the wave of Pacific Rim trade to a place on the map with the west coast Big Dogs: L.A., San Francisco, like that. The nub of the plan was to rescue downtown and the central core city from going the way of those bombed-out craters and shitholes back east like Detroit. The real-estate monkeys who run the place saw that Seattle was still mostly white folks, a lot of them having disposable income and credit, who didn’t particularly want to move to the burbs. They liked what the cities offer in all those brochures: services, culture, excitement, and so forth, and a chance to work close and fuck the commute.
The real estate guys got together and cooked up a pitch to sell yuppies wet dreams, and thereby make millions. Hey, folks, downtown living! Condos on clouds overlooking the bay! Heaven on Earth for Men in the Fastlane and Women of Power!
The You-Belong-To-the-City crowd lined up like ducks.
What a wet dream it was! They ripped out the old shit and trucked in the new. Corporate greed-heads, lured by the bright lights of China and sweet deals with the in-crowd, moved in. Dot Com got launched. Skyscrapers—leeched beige or Antarctic silver or black black black black, like those in all the millennium’s cities—shot up.
Ten thousand hotel rooms got built. New shops, boutiques, a new art museum a couple blocks south of the old kiddies’ ho stroll. A bus tunnel, built to haul shoppers and gawkers and grunts.
They tore the place up. Mid-eighties downtown Seattle looked like Beirut in the wake of Israeli cluster-bomb runs. The old crowd got rolled, along with the low-income housing. Pensioners, old folks, certified crazies huddled in SRO doorways or stacked up like cordwood on sidewalks down by the Courthouse.
Skid row got spitshined. Out went the muscatel watering holes. Strip joints and pool halls and peep shows got skunked. The El Coco Tavern got leveled and up went the Watermark Towers. Indians used to get squiffed on this spot for five bucks. Now, lawyers and fixers chow down on scampi and steak while they carve up the rest of the town, and get nicked for $250.
Then came the ‘90s. Not all the homeless got broomed. You could still see some roaming the alleys, dining in dumpsters, and snuggling on grates for the night, or until the cops come. There were dirt-caked, ragged-ass young guys sitting on sidewalks with dogs and tin cups. You’d see blitzed-out young mamas with kids, or no kids, and no hope. The missions and shelters were packed to the rafters, at least till their leases ran out.
Who else? Bottom-rung dopemen—though some of the top dogs, whites mostly, who also own banks and your mother, stayed up in those condos on clouds overlooking the bay…
Down by the Courthouse and north up on Third into Belltown, young brothers slung rock. On Pike, by the Market, the vatos had the concession on smack. It wasn’t the open-air drug zoo it was when the Cubans were ripping and running some 10 years before, but you still could get loaded easy enough. Rock was the only thing downtown had that was cheap. But you wouldn’t want to get fried and then sit on the sidewalk to groove on the day. They’d ticket your ass for just sitting. You wanted to get loaded, well, okay, cool, but you had to keep moving…
Looking to land, you’d likely hit Broadway, a hop up Capitol Hill to the east. Here was the glitter parade, a near-promenade, the word-of-mouth mecca and watering hole for Jet City’s young hip-eoisie. Chock to the brim with rock ‘n roll airheads, punk porno bimbos, dog-collared brokers, weed-sucking rastas, and bald-headed Nazis with lip rings; Jesus freak, muscle fags, Mao-shouting nitwits; 12-year-old glue-sniffing mutants from Kansas; toe sniffers, whip lickers, junkies with trust funds; lithium babies, panhandling grandmas; all sorts of strays with pins in their clits and no roadmap home. And, last but not least, boatloads of slummers from Bellevue, with charge-cards and take-off tattoos, who kept the place running.
You might wind up in Broadway’s spiritual ass-end, the gauntlet bounded by Denny and Pike running west to the freeway. A huddle of densely packed, faded apartments, and houses chopped into rooms. Filled up with schitzos and skag freaks, tweakers, parolees, drool cases, pensioned-off old folks, professional students, lower-end wage slaves, a cluster of registered sex fiends on Summit off Howell, unclassified geeks up the ying-yang—the shavings and sweepings of 20th Century life in the city. Could you dredge up the rent? Well, not for long; the yuppies were coming.
Till then, it was welcome home, baby…
Nineties Seattle! A cutting-edge city, the jump-off to 2001 and beyond! With the attitude sneering and bland, and a lah-de-dah shrug at the blood on the ground spilled by those who don’t make it.
The human condition? The haves and have-nots, all that shit? Pre-Dot Com dinosaur news!
Seattle was liberal, don’t get me wrong—and hip with a capital H to go with it. We knew about world beat, all that good stuff. The city used to be white-bread, but now, after Microsoft, lattes, that grunge shit, etc., we were, ah…well, white-bread…
But if ‘50s Seattle was Leave It To Beaver, 40 years later it was Birkenstock mamas and Superdads, trying to pretend that the Ma and Pa Cleaver act, tinctured a little with Gloria Steinem and New Age bibdribble, still made it. And maybe it did—if your income clocked in at six figures and mom didn’t have to stay home with the kids. She could if she cared to, of course…
Ideas in this town? People talked shop, relationship drama, the real-estate racket, the stock market, natch, nail polish gossip and updates, and, always, the Hawks and the Dawgs, blah-blah, blah-blah-blah. All the small change.
Along with rank bullshit from some other planet. You might stroll along Broadway and see some weedy professor in sandals and shorts that ballooned out in front and made him look pregnant or something. He’d be sitting there at the Café Septiem, sipping tea with his white bird legs crossed as the sun set on Broadway. A post-modern philosopher-dipshit, he’d be laying the moves on a young thing with cleavage, expounding the shopworn idea that ideas—the ones that seek to make sense of this world—are passé. Reality, he’d say, is your own little bubble, your fact is my fiction, life’s but a dream…on and on.
He’d allude he first read this in French in a sidewalk café on Montmartre. What a champ.
But real is real, n’est ce pas? That young thing had lungs, and hips that just wouldn’t quit. And that tuning-fork woody that dipshit had under his shorts there had weight, mass, duration, a short spitting distance—a monkey could have measured his whole philosophical interest, from prostate to foreskin, down to the last micro-inch.
How real was that one, sports fans?
Seattle was jumping with all kinds of real: Low dogs in high places, the war of the races… Check this one out: most of the folks in the King County Jail were black or some shade of brown, and still are. Now, as it happens, most all of the jailbirds were and are dopers. Yet seven out of ten of Jet City’s dope fiends back then just like now were as white as Prince Charles, or passing. So, why weren’t the white boys celled in? Were they out on a pass? Did the cops maybe lose them or something before they got booked? There’s an answer, I bet. But you sure wouldn’t find it by asking how come, or any of that stuff. What you’d get would be pasted-on blank looks, and maybe a feeling as if you’d broke wind in the middle of Tosca…
And so on.
Nineties Seattle. The 20th Century’s swan song…
A whole lot of water has vaulted the dam since those days. NASDAQ pancaked. The WTO and Fat Tuesday riots tore the town up. Boeing flipped us the bird and split town without telling the mayor. Then Broadway tanked it and Seattle sort of fell off the map of hot places.
Some things stayed the same: rents kept on climbing. A sizeable number of people continued to sleep under bridges, the freeway, in alleys, tent cities, and so forth.
Yuppie ethos metastasized big-time.
The hurt just kept coming. The real estate monkeys recycled the yuppies’ wet dream of two decades before and renamed it “high-density smart growth.” Which meant of course, gentrify, gentrify. Tear down old housing and slap up the condos. Watch real estate prices shoot way past Neptune. Watch poor folks and blue-collar drudges flee town like Okies in front of a dust storm.
And now they’re going to tear the Alaskan Way Viaduct down. Condos right on the water at last! The real estate monkeys get well once again and we’re stuck in gridlock forever.
At least we can say that Seattle’s in step with everywhere else. A good chunk of the world economy has gone off the cliff. People are starting to wake to the fact that the check is not in the mail. Meanwhile, we’re still at war, for the eight-trillionth year in a row, with no end in sight. The 21st Century is stone fucking drag time all over.
Purely local travail seems a bit of a chump-change concern.
How can mere dry-rot compare with the mess in Afghanistan, right?
Still, dry-rot is soul-killing stuff.
It sticks like a bone in the throat as the gray skies press down.



Oh, Robert. What will we do with you?
Now I take exception to the one sided presentation of the density planning. I think the idea of planning for mixed use “downtown” density centers is a good one because it changes the dynamics of auto dependency and allows for the human population to cluster perhpas leaving more uninterrupted open green space.
As you probably know, having token green spaces mixed in with humans is not adequate and does not provide diversity of habitats or allow for movement patterns. Animals don’t want to cross highways and hop fences. By pushing humans together, the green area remain more separate, distinct. At least in theory.
My problem is NOT with urban density but with the suburbs. With a mixed use downtown, you can have senior housing right in the heart of shopping. You can get to resources without a car. You can share costs as opposed to everyone with a spare buck heading for the hills.
I can go on about the planning issue, but I just wanted to say that there are some positive aspects, although gentrification can be a problem too. In some cases, blight rules and revitalization zones have led to improvements that all have enjoyed in measurable ways. What we don’t want is the donut hole of the seventies, the ghetto model, the urban flight.
We don’t want this sense of entitlement that we all deserve to plow everything under for our half acre and vinyl box. We have to rethink this, and I think sometimes mixed use density models are the way to go.
I think there are positive aspects too–in Europe. Here it’s all about quick-kill profits, slapping up condos for yuppies, driving up land prices and booting the poor folks and blue collar drudges out of town. That’s certainly what’s it’s all been about in Seattle. And yeah, they put it under the name of high-density smart growth–sounds better these days than gentrification and developers need to put tarp over truth–but it’s the same old scorched-earth policy it’s ever been. Money rules here, same as it does everywhere in America. Which means, fuck people, you know?
So, theoretically, I agree with you. But the way it’s invariably carried out in this country is bullshit.
Well it kind of leaves the cash strapped in limbo, because the high density housing is meant to be mixed and it isn’t in a lot of cases, it becomes high end and out of reach. It becomes a young hipster place vs working families. And I get that, I hear you. I think we are kind of making the distinction between how it should work and how it plays out. In theory, it can be a good thing but there has to be that connection between purpose and outcome.
“Mixed” means mixed, not gentrification. They forget that piece of it. And using the excuse of “blight” to tear down affordable housing to put up housing that the former tenants can’t possibly afford is exactly that, gentrification, you are right. But that isn’t the way it is SUPPOSED to happen.
I don’t know what the solution is in many cases, obviously a new building will be more desireable and demand would drive up rent in any scenario. And there is that very real problem of sub-standard housing with outdated utilities and toxins and mold.
I mean, does a planner leave that there? Does a city require that an “investor” keep the rent the same after the revitalization? Rent control?
I think this part is where people struggle, even those with good intentions. Which I am not saying they have everywhere, and the net effect is the same regardless of intent.
Used to be though that people of lower incomes could live and work in a metro area. Now they are pushed out and the suburbs are just as bad. In New York Metro, many low income people now have a two hour or more commute because the prices are just too high. It isn’t uncommon to find people who have picked up and moved further and further every few years. I have done that myself.
The emphasis has to be on “mixed”. So seniors, students, young, old, poor, professional, whatever…live together.
But the ugly truth under the tarp is that the American way is to get as far away from people who make less/live with less as you can. Put land between you, fences, costs, gates, restrictive covenants, whatever it takes to be surrounded by people you think are just like you.
In a planning meeting, somebody joked “where will low income people go?” and another quipped “Mexico!” and it was like this hilarious joke to them. It revealed a lot, huh?
Yup, it sure did. And, if you notice, all these “high-density” cocksuckers are doing their bit for suburban sprawl as well. That’s where they bounce all the poor folks…
I forgot, high density is also reaching its limits in capitalist Europe. Look at Paris; the inner city’s planned like a motherfucker, and increasingly out of reach for the working Yves. The suburbs though–wow! They’re metasticizing like yuppies, one reason being that the French like to stick all their immigrants there. The fire last time was nothing to what the fire next time’s gonna be over there.